Feature Story:
Baseball Legend Willie Mays Aikens Released Under Retroactivity Amendment
    By Zerline Jennings
    Willie Mays Aikens, former first baseman for the Kansas City Royals, made baseball history when he became the first player to have a pair of two-homer games in the 1980 World Series. Years later he made another kind of history when a longstanding addiction to cocaine ended his baseball career and ultimately led to a nearly 21-year sentence for selling crack cocaine to an undercover officer. Finally, in 2008, he again made headlines when a federal judge reduced his lengthy prison term to 14 years as a result of the U.S. Sentencing Commission’s recent adjustment to the crack cocaine sentencing guidelines. Aikens was released in June.

    “They used my case as an example to show that crack sentencing was cruel and unusual punishment,” said Aikens in an interview with WHNS-TV in South Carolina. “I’m glad that after spending 14 years in prison, something good came out of this.”

    Sentencing reform advocates utilized Aikens’ story to illustrate the unjust sentencing and racial disparities between crack and powder cocaine. After being convicted of attempting to purchase cocaine in 1983, his addiction eventually led to his suspension from major league baseball. He returned to Kansas City, after playing ball in Mexico, but continued to battle his addiction, which was quickly ruining his personal life as it had done his baseball career.

    Kansas City authorities were aware of Aikens' involvement with drugs. In December 1993, a female undercover officer established a friendship with Aikens and subsequently asked him to obtain crack cocaine for her on several occasions. On at least one occasion, the undercover officer specifically asked him to cook powder cocaine into crack cocaine.

    Entrapment and Mandatory Minimums
    With this evidence, the U.S. Attorney's office charged Aikens with multiple counts of trafficking crack cocaine. Because of harsher sentencing penalties for using and dealing crack, his sentence for selling 2.2 ounces of crack cocaine was treated as though equivalent to selling 15 pounds of powder cocaine.

    Aikens received a mandatory guideline sentence of 248 months in prison. Had the drug charges against him involved a similar amount of powder cocaine, Aikens would have been sentenced to about 27 months for the drug offense, plus an additional five years because the officer observed a shotgun at his residence.

    Rebuilding His Life
    Now 53 years old, Aikens has demonstrated remarkable progress in his rehabilitation. While incarcerated, he completed a 500-hour drug treatment program and established an exemplary record of good conduct. He maintained contact with his family including his two daughters, Lucia and Nicole. While in prison Aikens missed high school graduations and that celebratory moment when Nicole received an academic scholarship to Grinnell College in Iowa. But after his June 4 release, he has a second chance at fatherhood. He’s also already begun the hunt for employment – hoping to return to the ranks of baseball in some capacity.

    “I’m in a better frame of mind,” Aikens told the Kansas City Star. “I have a spiritual life now that I didn’t have before. I just look forward to being able to get out of prison and go out with those things and be able to live my life like I’m supposed to live it.”

    Aikens also kept in contact with his former teammates, coaches and friends including Cal Ripken, Jr., legendary baseball Hall of Famer, who, in November 2005, urged the Pardons Attorney at the Department of Justice to grant Aikens clemency. Ripken wrote in his letter to the Pardons Attorney:

    “[T]his man[Willie] who overcame poverty in childhood, [who] rose to fame as a professional athlete, who came so close to ruining his life with drugs and who has now set his feet on the path to recovery….has paid a heavy price for his self-destructive behavior. Willie should not be required to pay such a high price for the crime involved here, involving no-violence against others and no damage to anyone but Aikens himself.”

    Aikens also asked for clemency from President Clinton and was waiting on a request addressed to President Bush.

    “I’ve always had hope something would happen with my case,” Aikens told The State (Columbia, S.C.) newspaper.

    Zerline Jennings is the communications associate for The Sentencing Project. The Sentencing Project is a criminal justice research and advocacy organization based in Washington, DC. She can be contacted at zjennings@sentencingproject.org.


    Read more Crack the Disparity Newsletter articles:
    A Theological Basis for Ending the Sentencing Disparity, by Bill Medford
    Crack Cocaine Reform - The Struggle Continues, by Nkechi Taifa
    Grassroots Agenda: June, July, August, by Calli Schiller